Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Kulak's avatar
3dEdited

I have yet to be convinced that any "Elite Theory" posters have ever even READ Mosca or Pareto.

On the contrary all of them seem to have glanced at a Wikipedia page, and then used the vague affect of the words to justify their vibes.

the Itallian Elite theorists were not weird pessimists or nihilists... They were Economists!

Elite theory is entirely about politics in motion and how rivaled upstart elites (Ie. Poor political actors not unlike substackers or various right wing organizers (Patriot front, Dominion Society) either get co-opted, cycle into the elite, gradually replace the elite by buying them off to retire, or get shut out and militarize, and possibly fight revolutions...

It's all incredibly action packed and dynamic, its just hard to read and takes some shape-rotator brainpower because they model them with mathematical theory like economists hypothesizing market actors.

This is like reading a motorcycle mechanical handbook which says "The tire will not rotate without gas, air, spark, drive force, flywheel momentum, sufficient rpm, and intact drive chain and sprokets"

Then concluding Motorcycle design can be summarized in the slogan "The Tire will never rotate!" getting all that together is IMPOSSIBLE.

The Entire point of the Italian elite theorists was to create and manipulate new rivalled elites, entryist elites, and revolutionary elites...

The most famous reader and student of the Italian Elite Theorists was BENITO MUSSOLINI! You know the guy who violently marched on Rome and took over the Italian government and who Hitler studied.

.

It's as if one read Nicolo Machiavelli's "The Prince" then concluded a Prince could never exist... Because it sounds mean and stressful.

Harri Perkele's avatar

This particular formulation of elite theory as a "Black Lotus card to win any argument" seems to attract a certain type of personality. The spiteful, resentful and vulnerable narcissist kind.

159 more comments...

Ready for more?